Skip to content. | Skip to navigation

Personal tools
You are here: Home topics EU law Member States' compliance with EU law - Annual Report 2017

Member States' compliance with EU law - Annual Report 2017

12 July 2018
by eub2 -- last modified 12 July 2018

The European Commission's Annual Report on monitoring the application of EU law sets out how the Commission monitored and enforced EU law in 2017. The online Single Market Scoreboard, also published on 12 July, and marking the 25th anniversary of the EU Single Market, shows that whilst most barriers to the free movement of persons, services, goods and capital are being eliminated, in some fields the situation is stalling or even worsening.


The effective application of the law is seen as essential in order to guarantee that citizens and businesses enjoy the benefits of EU law. Any rule, no matter how carefully drafted and prepared, is only as effective as its implementation In driving forward its policy priorities, so the Commission pays attention not only to proposing new legislation, but also to ensuring that it is properly applied and enforced. For instance, in 2017, the Commission acted firmly in enforcing rules in the areas of data protection, migration, consumer protection, the fight against money laundering and terrorism financing or air quality.

At the same time, the cooperation between the Commission and the Member States in close partnership remains key in implementing EU law and in addressing any problems that may occur. Throughout the year, the Commission assisted Member States in their preparation for the entry into force of the General Data Protection Regulation (Regulation (EU) 2016/679).

Annual Report on Monitoring the application of EU law in 2017

The Annual Report for 2017 shows a slight decrease (by 5.91%) of open infringement cases compared to the previous year. Thus after reaching a five-year peak in 2016, the number of cases started to level off in 2017 (see Chart 1). However, each failure to correctly apply EU law denies citizens and businesses the rights and the benefits they enjoy under European law. In the area of environment, for example, the full transposition and implementation of the Directive on reducing the use of plastic bags is essential to address citizens' growing concerns about plastics.

The Chart 2 (below) provides an overview of the situation for each Member State. For late transposition cases, Belgium, Cyprus, and Portugal had the highest amount of open cases, whereas the fewest were open in Italy, Denmark, and Hungary. Spain, Italy and Germany had the highest number of cases pending for incorrect transposition and/or wrong application of EU law, while Denmark had the lowest total number of open cases last year.

The policy areas in which most infringement cases were opened in 2017 were mobility and transport, environment as well as financial stability, services and capital markets (see the Chart 3).

Combating late transposition of directives

For citizens and businesses to reap the benefits of EU law, it is crucial that Member States transpose European directives into their national legal order within the deadlines they had committed to.

In 2017, the number of new infringement procedures relating to late transposition decreased sharply by 34% (from 847 cases in 2016 to 558 in 2017) and is closer to 2015 level (543 cases). The Commission launched new infringement procedures against a majority of Member States for failure to transpose the Directives on the use of plastic bags, on waste and on the roadworthiness of vehicles.

To facilitate timely and correct transposition, the Commission continued to assist Member States by preparing implementation plans, dedicated websites and guidance documents, and by exchanging best practice in expert groups' meetings. For example, ahead of the entry into force of the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) on 25 May 2018, the Commission published already in January 2018 detailed guidance to help Member States apply the new rules in time.

Last year, the Commission referred five Member States to the Court of Justice of the EU requesting that financial penalties be applied: two cases against Belgium, two cases against Croatia, Slovakia, Slovenia and Spain (one case each).

Single Market Scoreboard 2018

The Single Market Scoreboard gives a detailed and accurate overview of the state of the implementation of the EU Single Market rules in the European Economic Area (EEA) in 2017. It evaluates how the EU and EEA Member States apply these rules and identifies the shortcomings where the countries and the Commission should step up their efforts.

Depending on their performance in 2017, Member States were given 152 green, 135 yellow and 49 red cards. The cards indicate in what areas they performed excellent (green), average (yellow) or below average (red).

The overview (see Chart 4 below) shows that Member States have improved in the recognition of professional qualification, the transposition of the Single Market-related rules and the development of tools supporting the good functioning of the Single Market on the ground (Your Europe, e-Certis, and EURES). But compared to the previous edition of the Scoreboard, Member States have also received more red cards in the areas of openness to cross-border trade in goods and services, fairness of public procurement systems and the number of infringement proceedings.

In general, the best performing countries were Finland, Denmark and Slovakia, while the highest number of red cards was given to the Czech Republic, Ireland and Greece.

The Commission reacts to citizens' complaints

Citizens, businesses, NGOs and other stakeholders can report suspected breaches of EU law through an online complaint form accessible via the Europa portal Your rights. In 2017, the majority of complaints concerned justice and consumer rights, employment, EU Single Market, industry and SMEs matters. As part of the complaint form, SOLVIT can help citizens and businesses solve their problems with a public authority in another EU country.


The annual Single Market Scoreboard evaluates how Member States:

- implement EU rules;

- create open and integrated markets (e.g. public procurement, trade in goods and services);

- handle administrative issues concerning foreign workers (e.g. professional qualifications);

- cooperate and contribute to a number of EU-wide governance tools (e.g. Your Europe portal, Solvit, and EURES)

This year marks 25th anniversary of the EU Single Market. The anniversary edition of the Single Market Scoreboard evaluates performance in four policy areas, two areas regarding market openness and integration, and 13 governance tools.

a) Annual Report on Monitoring the application of EU law in 2017:

- Annual report on national implementation of EU law

- Fact sheets by country

- EU-28 fact sheet

- On the general EU infringement procedure, see a full MEMO of 17/01/2012.

b) Single Market Scoreboard (edition 2018):

- Scoreboard

- Fact sheets by country

- Performance overview

Source: European Commission

Sponsor a Guide

EUbusiness Guides offer background information and web links about key EU business issues.

Promote your services by providing your own practical information and help to EUbusiness members, with your brand and contact details.

To sponsor a Guide phone us on +44 (0)20 7193 7242 or email sales.

EU Guides