Skip to content. | Skip to navigation

Personal tools
Sections
You are here: Home Members Testbiotech EU Court of Justice strengthens the precautionary principle

EU Court of Justice strengthens the precautionary principle

14 March 2018
by testbiotech -- last modified 16 March 2018

The Court of Justice of the EU (CJEU) today confirmed the right of civil society organisations to submit legal cases concerning the health risks of genetically engineered plants.


Advertisement

The case was prompted by market authorisation being issued for the import of genetically engineered soybeans produced by US companies Monsanto and DuPont/ Pioneer which, according to analysis undertaken by Testbiotech and other experts, have not been adequately investigated for health risks. The EU Commission wanted to prevent Testbiotech from initiating a legal revision of a decision allowing the import of these genetically engineered soybeans. In response, Testbiotech filed a precedent case at the Court of Justice of the EU (CJEU) to gain access to justice (T-33/16). The CJEU today confirmed the rights of Testbiotech.

"The EU Commission has allowed the import of genetically engineered soybeans despite concerns about the risks to human health. In addition, the Commission tried to prevent the CJEU from re-examining the approval," says Christoph Then for Testbiotech. "The decision today is an important step towards strengthening the precautionary principle in the EU."

In May 2015, Testbiotech together with GeneWatch UK, filed a complaint against the authorisation issued for the import of genetically engineered soybeans that are changed in their oil quality. The EU Commission exceeded the legally defined time-frame for its response by more than a month. Then, in its answer, the Commission claimed that according to the relevant EU Regulation 1367/2006 only risks concerning the environment could be reviewed, but not the risks to human health. Today this legal interpretation was rejected by the CJEU.

Testbiotech has filed two other cases at the EU court against imports of genetically engineered soybeans. One of these is against genetically engineered soybeans developed by Monsanto that produce insecticidal proteins. Amongst others, there are concerns that the insecticidal proteins intensify the immune reaction to allergens which occur in soybeans (C-82/17 P). A further case concerns genetically engineered soybeans developed by Bayer that are engineered to be resistant to several herbicides. However, the health risks associated with the consumption of such beans were not assessed (T-173/17).

Testbiotech considers these legal cases to be test cases breaking new ground in legal jurisdiction. Now that legal clarity has been provided and these legal revisions are admissible, the EU court has to clarify in more detail how it will deal with scientifically-based concerns and the role of the precautionary principle. In addition, Testbiotech wants to see more clarity on the burden of proof incumbent on the EU Commission to provide evidence of safety. Despite today's decision these questions are still not finally settled. Indeed, Testbiotech has already forwarded several questions to the highest level of the EU court to find out more about how the court in general deals with scientifically-based concerns in this context (C-82/17 P).

Testbiotech was founded in 2008 by a group of experts and registered as a non-profit organisation to promote independent research and public debate on the impacts of biotechnology. Testbiotech is a centre of expertise concerned mainly with the ecological, social and ethical consequences of modern biotechnology.

Testbiotech
Become a Partner

Partnership gives you:

  • Your own section on EUbusiness.com - with your press releases, position papers, events, job vacancies etc
  • Each content item linked from topic channels where your organisation has expertise
  • Listing on Partners page
  • Branded with your logo and links

For further details on becoming a Partner, contact email salesSales by email, or phone Nick Prag on +44 (0)20 8058 8232.

Membership options